Public Adjuster Reviews & Testimonials
Claim Payments Are 747% Higher Using a Public Adjuster. According to the Florida Legislature’s Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability (OPPAGA), policyholders who hired public adjusters for hurricane-related claims received 747% more money than those who did not — $17,187 per claim versus $2,029.
“The work of public adjusting is defined by the noble work of helping someone navigate a path they have no way of navigating themselves.” — Jeff Atwater, former Florida Chief Financial Officer
Proven Claim Increases
When the carrier’s estimate is too low, we challenge it. Below are real claim increases: the carrier’s estimate next to what we recovered.
+432% in claim increases. Carrier estimates totaled $416,531.68. We recovered over $2,215,993.95.
Scot: +4,415%. Carrier’s estimate: $6,079.06. Recovered: $274,450.46.
Mike: +3,559%. Carrier’s estimate: $3,548.08. Recovered: $129,829.29.
Debra: +1,403%. Carrier’s estimate: $17,209.99. Recovered: $258,587.23.
Sam: +219%. Carrier’s estimate: $106,751.83. Recovered: $340,289.91.
Theresa and Joseph: +304%. Carrier’s estimate: $148,626.88. Recovered: over $600,000.
Rajiv and Swati: +356%. Carrier’s estimate: $134,315.84. Recovered: $612,837.06.
Rhonda and Mark: +72,299%. Frontline inspected their Hurricane Milton damage three times and sent a first check of $66.60. Recovered: $48,226.19.
Commercial: +157%. A commercial client’s multiple-six-figure claim, increased 157%.
Condo Association — Naples, Florida
Hurricane Irma, September 2017
A 14-building condominium association in Naples, Florida. When Hurricane Irma struck in September 2017, every building sustained damage, primarily to the roofs.
The association’s board filed the claim on its own. The carrier answered with delay tactics, shuffled the claim between several different adjusters, and months later had made little progress. Its initial offer covered only minor repairs — repairs the local building department would not even permit.
The board brought us in for an independent review. We inspected every building alongside the carrier’s representatives, demonstrated that matching replacement tiles were no longer available for repairs, and performed generally accepted engineering tests that proved far more damage than first reported. Between the direct loss, the consequential loss, and the application of local building codes, the roofs were paid for complete replacement.
The settlement is confidential, so the exact figure cannot be published. It was millions of dollars higher than the carrier initially reserved for this loss.
“I’ve worked with Nathan Sheppard, the Policyholder Advocacy Group since 2009. In that time we’ve served hundreds of clients together — homeowners and commercial property owners — and their work has driven millions of dollars in revenue for my roofing business.
Nathan takes insurance claims that were denied or grossly underpaid, particularly after hurricanes, and turns them into full roof replacements. I’ve watched him take cases where insurers claimed damage was pre-existing or offered pennies, and secure the funding for proper repairs on everything from single-family homes to large commercial buildings.
He reviews the policy, gathers the evidence, and fights for every dollar.
— Dave Peck, Owner, D Peck Roofing
Sam K. — Hurricane Ian
“My insurance company offered me a fraction of what my Hurricane Ian damage was worth. I couldn’t have done this without him.”
— Sam K., Hurricane Ian Claim
Facebook Reviews
19 July at 23:58Nathan Sheppard is truly a miracle worker! The insurance company was only going to pay a small portion of my repair claim. Needless to say, my insurance binder was a very lengthy document with insurance jargon and terminology that I never could have understood or would have thought to question. Nathan analyzed my policy and combined with his thorough knowledge of the industry was able to obtain the FULL repair costs at today's replacement value! Something I could have never accomplished on my own. Great job Nathan!
15 December 2016Nate is a great honest guy looking out for the best of me, if you want great service these are the people you want to deal with!
15 August 2016Life was raining down on me in a big way in June and July 2016. To top it off I found a leak that was under the slab foundation of my home. I noticed the leak through high water bills essentially catching the problem earlier rather than later. However, my insurance company denied my claim and refused to help me fix the problem. I was completely overwhelmed and was considering just letting my home of 20 years go. While working at my house a plumber referred me to PAG and Nathan came out within hours of receiving my call. Nathan reviewed my policy and explained exactly what I was entitled to based on the limits of my policy. He guided me in exactly how to proceed in proving there was a covered loss. Step by step Nathan provided quick and effective assistance, and took additional time to make sure I understood everything. he explained my policy to me in depth pointing out areas of concern with the policy. He provided assistance and recommendations on Insurance coverage and policies. I really appreciate the fact that Nathan took time to educate me on the options available to me as a consumer. His advice will serve me for years to come.
And finally due to the ridiculously low water damage coverage Nathan gave me a huge (ENORMOUS) break on his normal charges so that I would have enough money to actually repair the damage. WELL WORTH THE CALL!
11 July 2016I got fantastic help and over $10,000 from a roof claim that I otherwise wrote off as never going to happen. Please give them a call with any water damage before you have it repaired. You may be surprised to what you're entitled to like I was.
12 May 2016They do a great job! Highly recommend anyone with water damage.
18 November 2016Rated 5.0 Out of 5 by Our Clients
Real reviews from real policyholders. Read them where they were posted, in the reviewers' own words.
Google Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars ★★★★★ from 3 reviews
JoAnn Orr. After a home invasion claim, PAG guided the process, documented the losses, and dealt with the carrier. She and her husband recovered what they needed to repair and replace.
Glen Upton. His carrier denied his water damage claim outright. PAG got the claim resolved. He redid his kitchen, replaced the floors throughout the house, and repainted the interior. He recommends PAG.
Erin McWhorter Jones. "I highly recommend Policyholder Advocacy Group. They are incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely passionate about helping property owners navigate the insurance claims process."
Trustpilot Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars ★★★★★ from 1 review
Erin McWhorter Jones. She highly recommends Policyholder Advocacy Group. Read her full review on Trustpilot.
More Testimonials From Our Clients
Google Reviews From Past Years
These reviews were posted on Google from 2016 to 2019. We recovered the full text from our own records.
JoAnn Orr (Google, January 13, 2016)
"I do not know what we would have done without the help of the Policyholder Advocacy Group. We experienced a break-in to our home and subsequently major damage. Our insurance company offered $3000 for the repairs. It would have been impossible to repair all the damage with only $3000. We hired an independent company and their estimate to repair all the damages to the floors, walls, tile.....$40,000. I called the Policyholder Advocacy Group (PGA) to see if there was anything they could do to help us. That was the last call I had to make......they handled all the paperwork, brought in additional estimators and I am thrilled to say we received a check for $40,000. They were professional, have the knowledge and expertise to help homeowners and I am sure business owners tackle the insurance companies. Thank you.....PAG.....J. Orr"
Tom Gannon (Google, February 10, 2016)
"Nathan with The Policyholder Advocacy Group has worked with our company for many years on projects ranging from small water and fire damage claims, to working multi million dollar sinkhole projects. Nathan has brought a wealth of knowledge, policy expertise and work ethic to help our clients handle their claims. Without Nathan's help many of our clients would not have been compensated adequately if at all, or been able to complete their repairs to make them whole. I highly recommend The Policyholder Advocacy Group to handle your insurance claim from start to finish."
Brooke Boyd (Google, April 6, 2016)
"Policyholder Advocacy Group works on behalf of their clients, NOT the insurance company. They are able to get the maximum settlement monies, truly fighting for their clients. I would completely recommend their services any day."
Vinnie Campagna (Google, July 10, 2016)
"Nathan as able to successfully get us over $10,000 for a roof leak claim that was otherwise immediately denied. Please, you owe it to yourself before you fix some water damage from the roof, kitchen or bathroom to at least talk to Nathan and see what he can do for you."
Google kept only the opening lines of these reviews in its notification emails. We show them exactly as they arrived.
Tammy (Google, June 11, 2018, 5 stars)
"The Policyholder Advocacy Group came highly recommended to me due to the complexity of my case and..."
Thomas (Google, July 8, 2018, 5 stars)
"Nathan is a miracle worker and was able to get our insurance company to own-up and cover the costs..."
Cheryl (Google, September 18, 2018, 5 stars)
"Nathan couldn't be more professional. But the help he offered was far and above anything we..."
Noelle Thomas (Google, January 18, 2016, 5 stars)
"The nightmare began in Feb 2015..."
More Facebook Reviews
Kerry Sutton Planeta (Facebook, October 30, 2019)
"Nathan was excellent throughout the entire process. He is very professional and extremely knowledgeable. I would recommend him for sure!"
Stephen Perron (Facebook, October 21, 2019)
"There are times you need professional advice, and an insurance claim is one of them. Nathan was able to educate me as far of the process and advocate on my behalf. The result was more than I expected. I highly recommend Nathan to represent you."
Cheryl Pekarek Cusack (Facebook, September 18, 2018)
"Nathan is a true professional and has helped us on two separate insurance issues. We would have had to foot the entire loss bill ourselves until Nathan got involved. Can't sing Nathan's praises more. He is the man for the job!"